The first thing you need to understand is that the secret to choosing essay topics your teachers will love IS NOT WHAT YOU THINK.
No. It’s not.
It’s not something that:
- Will make your teacher happy.
- Is so politically correct that it’s boring and puts your teacher to sleep
- Will impress your teacher with your genius
- Is longer than anyone else’s
- Is perfectly grammarized and punctuated
- Is what you think your teacher wants
No.
=====================
The secret to choosing a topic
your teacher or professor will love is
====================
To pick something that comes from an emotional reaction inside you to the subject, question, prompt or situation you’ve been asked to write about. In other words:
- Something that sets off a reaction, either positive or negative, in relation to the idea or ideas you have to write about.
- Something that triggers an agreement or disagreement inside you.
If you think this is the weirdest thing you’ve ever heard from a teacher and that I’m crazy, I understand. Hang with me for a moment and I’ll explain.
=========================
Why this is the fastest and easiest way
to find a grade-raising essay topic
=========================
Because your emotional reaction is a clue—from yourself to yourself—that you actually have something to say about this topic, subject, prompt, question, idea or situation.
And the coolest thing is, all of the ideas you need to be able to write a grade-raising essay or paper, which means a persuasive essay or paper where you:
- Take a Position on your topic
- Create 3 Proof Points that back up your position
- Find 3 Proof Details for each one of your 3 point
are sitting there—just under your emotional reaction—waiting for you to bring them to the surface which you do by asking yourself a few simple questions.
=======================
Here’s the seldom-taught reason why
your teacher will respond positively
when you write from an emotional reaction
=======================
Because when you get emotional and write from some sort of feeling (even a tiny little one), your emotion will cause an emotional reaction in your reader, (in this case, your grader), and make an emotional connection between your paper and them.
In writer’s terms, this connection hooks them into your paper and once they’re hooked emotionally, they will be a lot more interested than usual in what you have to say.
You may not think this matters. But it does.
Because 95% of student papers and essays are boring. Mind numbingly boring. Especially when they are all about the same subject.
Double especially when a teacher has 80-120 kids writing about the same topic or prompt.
The main reasons the papers are boring are because most students:
- Don’t care about the subject
- Don’t like to write
- Don’t like finding and using their own idea
- Will basically be spewing the same facts they found in their textbooks or from different lectures
- Wait until the last minute to start which makes it hard to have enough time to write and edit a good persuasive paper
How do I know?
Because I’ve been doing surveys with high school kids for 2 years and they told me.
And as you know from reading textbooks—reading fact after fact after fact without the subject making any emotional kind of connection with you while your reading—is BORING! Mind numbingly boring.
Am I right or am I right?
Therefore, making some sort of emotional connection between you and the subject—and then your paper and your teacher—is the #1 grade-raising topic picking secret.
Now, I realize you’ve probably never heard this before from any teacher.
- The #1 reason is because they don’t understand this
- The #2 reason is, they don’t know how to teach it is because they’ve never been taught how (so it’s really not their fault)
- And the #3 reason is because they aren’t professional writers who realize it’s impossible to write anything that people will want to read without making some kind of emotional, intellectual and/or spiritual connection with the reader.
==================
Let me give you an example
from my playwriting life
of how quickly this
emotional reaction hook thing
can work and how to use this secret
for your next essay or paper.
==================
How an emotional reaction hooked me in and led to the creating, writing and success of “The Bah of Humbug”
“The Bah” is a play I wrote that I wasn’t planning to write in October of 1980. (Yeah, I’m a pretty old dude but that’s actually lucky for you because I’ve lived long enough to understand how this works and can actually explain it to you).
I wasn’t planning to write the play but did due to an emotional reaction I had from to a brief conversation with a school principal that pissed me off. (Yeah, I used the dreaded “P” word but that was the emotional reaction I had so it’s ok.)
Here’s What Happened.
I was 27 years old. I’d been working at this school for a couple of years as a writer and theatre guy in residence. I’d written one musical, “Columbus, Where Are You?”, which we’d done with 5th and 6th graders the semester before and was a huge success.
The old principal who liked me retired and this new guy came in. He was a crummy communicator and wasn’t very popular among the teachers, the students or the parents.
One morning, I was walking down the hallway to my room and he was walking towards me.
He stopped and asked if I was planning to do anything for the Christmas Holiday Show. (This was in 1980 when it was still OK to use the word Christmas at Christmas time in public schools. Told you I was old.)
Anyways, I told him I usually didn’t because the teachers liked to do holiday stuff with their classes and my smaller groups of kids were pulled from regular classes so we usually did things at other times of year.
He listened, didn’t say anything for a moment, then points one finger towards me and says, “Well, think about it,” and turns his wrist so his finger twists up towards me.
It was an odd thing to do and it made my head jerk back a little.
Then he smiled, put his finger down and continued down the hall leaving me standing there.
I shook my head and started walking, repeating the words, “Just, think about it” over and over until I got to my classroom.
The more I said it, the more annoyed I got and in a few minutes the group of 15 kids came in for their hour drama class.
=================
Here’s where the emotional hook takes over…
=================
I hadn’t decided what play this group would be doing yet. So I told them the story of what just happened and finish by saying, “If we can come up with a funny story that combines Christmas and Hanukkah, I’ll write it up and if you all like it, I’ll turn it into a play and we’ll do it for Christmas.”
They thought that was cool and for an hour we tossed around all kinds of goofy ideas. By the end of the hour the best one was “Santa is kidnapped on Christmas eve while riding on his skakeboard.”
At the end of the hour, I added that he gets kidnapped by the meanest man in the world. The guy who wants to ruin Christmas for everyone. And because it’s Christmas Eve, nobody’s working so they have to find some Jewish Detectives who can help them find Santa.
I liked the idea (the emotional hook goes in further) so I go home and over the next few days I fleshed out the story. I called the mean guy “The Bah of Humbug” and named the Jewish detectives after the hero’s of Hanukkah. And had Rudy (the talking reindeer) go with them on a quest that sort of follows the story of Christmas until they track down the evil Bah, capture him and save Christmas.
When I read the story to the group the next week, they loved it. Which hooked me in further, turned on the inspiration juice and I wrote the original version of the Bah, 33 pages, in one week. (It’s now twice as long but the same basic story.)
We put it together and performed it 6 weeks later.
The most amazing thing of all was, “The Bah” was an instant hit.
The entire school demanded a sequel, which turned out to be “The Easter Bah” and led to a 3rd play called “A Witches Choice” and my not-yet-thought-of after school drama program which allowed me to make a living directing plays with kids for the next 5 years.
We even did “The Bah” at St. Vincent’s Academy in Savannah in 2007 with high school kids, 27 years after that guy said, “Well, think about it.”
And again it was a big success.
The major takeaway from this story (the thing I want you to understand) is this entire idea and the final product all came from my original emotional reaction to the principal saying “Well, think about it,” and twisting his finger towards my face.
======================
There’s a second part to this success secret
which turned out to be more important
than getting the original idea.
And it is…
I turned the original reaction
INTO AN IDEA
and turned that idea INTO
AN ACTUAL PHYSICAL FORM
======================
A form people could do something with.
In this case, it turned into a play which we performed.
A form people can read, act out, watch and respond to.
In your case, it will be a physical paper people can read silently or out loud and respond to.
Now, if you think the creation of my play and the creation of your paper are different because they are two different forms—they aren’t.
This way of inventing things is called working with the Creative Process.
And the most effective creations always start with the creator’s intellectual, emotional and/or spiritual reaction to something in his life or the world that moves him enough to do something with it.
You may not have as big a reaction or write as much as I did. That doesn’t matter. The theory and process are the same. And will work for you too.
======================
How to use this secret to choose
an essay topic you’ll have lots to write about
======================
If you are starting from a PROMPT—
Which is a question or phrase your teacher gave you…
Ask yourself:
“Do I AGREE or DISAGREE with the phrase
or
have a YES or NO answer to the question?”
Now listen close because this is the key to the whole thing…
Your agreement or yes—or disagreement or no—
is your TOPIC for this paper.
And the reason why you agree or disagree will be the Position or side you’ll take and prove with the rest of your paper.
I’ll get into taking a postion and finding all the proof you need to write a persuasive essay or paper in a future blog post. For now, let’s stick to nailing down a topic.
If you want to use The Bah of Humbug as a finding a topic example, it works like this…I’m thinking…I never had to look at it this way before and didn’t know I was going to until I wrote this sentence…
…hmm…tricky…hmm…scary…can I even come up with something?…ah hah!
The weird principal actually suggested I “think about” doing a Christmas Holiday show. That was like a prompt, wasn’t it? A prompt I didn’t like and disagreed with.
My idea for an actual topic was to come up with a story that combined both Christmas and Hanukah in a fun, silly and different way.
And because it came out of my resentment over what the principal had said and done, I had an emotional attachment to the idea. An emotion I needed to get the feeling and idea out of my head and share it with the class and led us to come up with a simple story outline that I could take and make into a complete story.
And there it is.
- A topic.
- That came from an emotional reaction.
- That led to a position.
- That inspired an idea I could outline.
- And turn into an actual written piece.
And it all started with that first emotional reaction. Which is all you ever need to get started too.
If that seems too easy, it may be.
But that’s all you need to begin anything.
And it’s that easy because this isn’t rocket science. It just feels like rocket science when you haven’t been shown an easy way to do it. So don’t make harder than it needs to be.
=================
If your teacher doesn’t give you a prompt
and you have to choose an essay topic and
position and start from SCRATCH…
================
It’s a little harder.
So review all of your class notes, lecture notes, browse through whatever chapters in your textbook or novel have to do with the assignment—and as you do—be on the alert for any positive or negative feeling or little zing of emotion you get as you are looking.
As soon as you feel something, positive or negative—stop.
Because that’s the emotional reaction you want.
Then quickly write down:
- What you felt
- Why you felt it
- What part of the subject or situation your reaction was in reaction to
That feeling or reaction to is your TOPIC.
And your Reason Why—is your POSITION
for your paper.
———————————————-
This is trickier to explain so lets use
“The Bah of Humbug” as an example
for starting from scratch.
———————————————-
My original emotional reaction to the principal twisting his finger in my face was being offended by his attitude and gesture.
A few minutes later, when speaking to the group of kids, I was still stuck in the feeling. Not only was I stuck but I was starting to get resentful and mad.
I needed to do something with the feeling and being a writer and a teacher who needed something for this class to do—my solution was to come up with a story that combined Christmas and Hanukkah in a silly way and if we got something interesting, I’d turn it into a story and if the kids liked it, a play that we could do.
The idea of a story that combined Christmas and Hanukkah in a silly way was my topic.
My position, which came after we got the idea that Santa was kidnapped on Christmas Eve, was to have both sides work together to rescue Santa and save Christmas.
Which was different and something I’d never seen done before but made sense in our situation because the class (and the school) was part Jewish and part Christian and no one really knew anything aobut the other groups holiday.
(If you’re in a public school and can’t do stuff that combines holidays like this, I understand and am using this as an example of how writers get ideas. Remember, this happened 29 years ago when it was OK.)
Obviously, I hadn’t thought of any of this before the incident with the principal. It all happened lightning fast and had an unexpected payoff that’s affected my life in good way for almost 30 years.
This is what can happen when you just go with your reaction to things, turn them into something positive, get started and see what happens.
I had no idea when I got the idea if it’d be any good or not. Or if I turned the story into a play if the play would be any good.
You won’t know how your paper will turn out when you choose a topic and a position either.
You just get an idea, try it and find out.
================
If you want more help choosing an essay topic
starting from a Prompt or From Scratch—
Here are two easy ways to get it…
================
Get yourself a copy of “How To Plan, Write and Edit a Grade Raising Essay—in less time, with less work and less stress”
One section is called “The Essay Topic Idea Generator” and it will walk you through this process successfully in less than 10 minutes.
You can get the book from me by mailing a check for $49.97 to:
Rick Goldman
1908 Colonial Drive
Savannah, GA 31406
The tool kit comes with my “Raise Your Writing Grade or Bust 100% Money Back Guarantee” so if it doesn’t help you raise your writing grade on your next paper or you just don’t like it once you get it—you can easily get your money back. And I’ll pay for shipping.
=======================
If you’d like a Private Essay Writing Tutoring Session
(in person in Savannah or over the phone
anywhere else in the U.S. )
where I walk you (college students and teachers)
or you and your child (middle and high school students)
through the whole planning, writing and editing
of your essay—
Here’s what to do next…
======================
Middle and High School Students and Parents—Show each other this blog and then have them have a parent call me at 912-660-5353 between 9 AM and 7 PM eastern time.
College Students—call me yourself at 912-660-5353 between 9 AM and 7 PM eastern time.
If no one answers, leave a message with your phone number and I’ll call you back.
Your tutoring sessions also include a copy of “How To Plan, Write and Edit a Grade Raising Essay” and come with my “Raise Your Writing Grade or Bust 100% Money Back Guarantee” so you actually get your money back if I can’t help you raise your writing grade.
If you are interested in having me be your or your child’s Grade-Raising Essay Writing Tutor and want to know what other parents, kids and educators say about the program, read the Testimonials page of this blog. Then give me a call.
======================
That’s it for today.
Keep writing and keep coming back to this blog for more ideas and help and be sure to tell your friends, parents and fellow educators about it.
And leave a comment in the comment box below if you have a quick question.
Thanks,
Rick Goldman, the Grade Raising Essay Writing Coach
© 2009 by Rick Goldman